Peter pines after his college roommate Craig Rhodes, a blond BMOC and son of a politician who’s as straight as an arrow. Peter tries to make a grab for Craig’s cock on their first day in their dorm, but Craig rebuffs him and offers to fix him up with a girl. Peter ends up tormented for weeks until opportunity finally strikes. Craig pulls a leg muscle while showing off for a group of girls and Peter gets him home with the help of his friend Mike. Craig doesn’t want a doctor, so Mike offers him poppers before leaving. Craig gets high huffing the poppers and Peter offers to give him a rub-down massage. Naturally, Peter jacks himself off while sucking Craig’s cock.

Mike returns with a thug named Durrell and waits outside Peter and Craig’s dorm while Durrell knocks Peter out and ties him up. Then he helps Durrell drug and kidnap Craig. In his knocked-out state, Peter dreams that he and Craig are 69’ing. Then Mike returns, unties Peter and tells him that Craig has been kidnapped and they need to contact Craig’s politician father for the ransom.

Craig wakes up, bound naked in the lair of Durrell and his partner Jock. Jock is a crook that Craig’s father once had the opportunity to have arrested, but he passed it up. Jock sends Durrell to make the ransom call, and left alone, takes the opportunity to have sex with Craig. He tugs on his cock, kisses him, then strips and climbs onto the table Craig is bound to and feeds him his cock. Durrell returns and half-heartedly tugs on his cock. Jock then cums in Craig’s mouth and Craig licks his lips, like he’s suddenly smitten. Jock lets Craig loose from his binds and Durrell blows a gasket and storms off. Jock and Craig then lay down on a mattress on the floor and Jock fucks Craig. Jock asks Craig how he compares to Peter, and Craig says that Peter’s no comparison, that Jock really turns him on. They 69 briefly, then Jock fucks Craig again and this time admits that when he was younger, Craig’s dad caught him breaking and entering. Instead of turning him in, he captured Jock and raped him for a week and that’s the whole reason for the kidnapping.

Craig’s dad asks Peter to deliver the ransom. Peter lurks when the ransom is picked up and chases the thug who picks it up and realizes it’s Mike when he gets to their lair. Mike flees, but Durrell stops Peter from chasing him further. He takes him inside and Peter is crestfallen when he realizes that Craig is now a willing part of the scheme. Durrell ties Peter to a rack, with his arms above his head. He whips him with a belt and teases him with a knife while Jock and Craig watch. When Jock and Peter drop to the floor and Craig starts sucking Jock’s cock, Durrell lets Peter free and forces him to his knees to suck his cock. Peter keeps sneaking glances at Craig sucking Jock, and imagines that it’s Craig’s cock he’s sucking. Durrell then bends Peter over a a table and fucks him while Craig and Jock watch on. Craig looks turned on by the whole thing, then Durrell begins fisting Peter while he screams in pain. The fisting goes on for a couple minutes, then Craig finally decides he’s had enough when Peter passes out. He busts a bottle over Durrell’s head. When Jock tries to intercede, Craig grabs Durrell’s knife and threatens to kill Jock. He tells him that he’s choosing Peter now, and that Jock can leave with Durrell now that he’s gotten the money and revenge on Craig’s father. Craig then wakes Peter up and says they’re alone. They kiss, then get dressed and run off together and Peter’s voiceover narration explains that it’s a year later and they’re still together.