Nathaniel Arnold (Andre Donovan) is back in his hometown for his father's funeral. The place is steeped in memories for him, and many of those memories include Tony Lyons (Adam Ramzi). The two had a clandestine relationship in high school. Though time has passed, there's still a connection between Nathaniel and Tony. They explore the relationship while exploring themselves.

Years after graduating, Sam Romero (Jack Bailey) gets in touch with his former English teacher, Mr. Howard Dennison (Greg McKeon). After reconnecting on social media, they decide to meet up. Sam is grateful to Howard for allowing him to be himself with him and understand that it's okay to be who you are without apologies. Their affection and tenderness turns sexual as they realize that their growing feelings are mutual.