Jeffrey (Dante Colle) is a closeted man who is full of fears and trepidition about his identity. Though he's a successful doctor, he struggles with his inner voice telling him there's something wrong with him and his proclivities. It takes Lance (Dakota Payne), a handsome new confidante, to help Jeffrey on his first steps to self-acceptance.

Charles Fischer (Trevor Harris) has always been great at school, so he's not surprised when yet another jock asks him to 'study' together. Fully prepared to do Brendan Monroe's (Justin Matthews) homework for him. To his surprise, Brendan is more like Charles than the geeky, gay student realizes.

In Riley Mitchel's day it wasn't as socially acceptable to be gay, that's why he had such a hard time when his son came out. He's learning to accept it, and he's even attending his son's kickback. When Riley meets Elliot Finn at the get together, he admits to Elliot and himself that maybe he might be gay too.